The Literal Arc Problem
"Your character arc is flat."
"He's a pancake."
"Metaphorically?"
"Literally. Chapter 4. Witch."
Discover interesting content about books and writing
"Your character arc is flat."
"He's a pancake."
"Metaphorically?"
"Literally. Chapter 4. Witch."
Beta reader returns manuscript.
'Loved it. Changed nothing. Perfect.'
This is useless. Suspiciously useless. No notes? No 'maybe reconsider page 47'? Not even a single 'unclear'?
I check the email address.
Mom, we talked about this.
Beta reader calls at midnight: "Chapter 5 made me cry."
Me: "It's a comedy."
Beta reader: "I know."
A writer receives feedback on their latest novel.
Reader: "The pacing was great, characters were compelling, but I have to say - the ending felt incredibly abrupt—"
My friend asked me to beta read her fantasy novel. 'Be brutally honest,' she said. I pointed out seventeen plot holes, four timeline inconsistencies, and a dragon that changed colors mid-chapter. She hasn't spoken to me in six months. Turns out 'brutally honest' is author-speak for 'praise me specifically but make it sound like feedback.'
"Your character arc is flat." "He's a pancake." "Metaphorically?" "Literally. Chapter 4. Witch."
Beta reader returns manuscript. 'Loved it. Changed nothing. Perfect.' This is useless. Suspiciously useless. No notes? No 'maybe reconsider page 47'? Not even a single 'unclear'? I check the email address. Mom, we talked about this.
Beta reader calls at midnight: "Chapter 5 made me cry." Me: "It's a comedy." Beta reader: "I know."
A writer receives feedback on their latest novel. Reader: "The pacing was great, characters were compelling, but I have to say - the ending felt incredibly abrupt—"
My friend asked me to beta read her fantasy novel. 'Be brutally honest,' she said. I pointed out seventeen plot holes, four timeline inconsistencies, and a dragon that changed colors mid-chapter. She hasn't spoken to me in six months. Turns out 'brutally honest' is author-speak for 'praise me specifically but make it sound like feedback.'
Nothing to read? Create your own book and read it! Like I do.
Create a book"A word after a word after a word is power." — Margaret Atwood
Loading comments...