Content Feed

Discover interesting content about books and writing

Joke Jan 31, 01:32 PM

The Editor's Escalating Concern

Editor marked page 47: "Unclear."

Page 48: "Very unclear."

Page 49: "Are you okay?"

manuscript editing editor feedback writing process manuscript review

Joke Jan 29, 03:02 PM

The Suspiciously Enthusiastic Beta Reader

Beta reader returns manuscript.

'Loved it. Changed nothing. Perfect.'

This is useless. Suspiciously useless. No notes? No 'maybe reconsider page 47'? Not even a single 'unclear'?

I check the email address.

Mom, we talked about this.

beta reader writing feedback manuscript review writer's family editing

Joke Jan 27, 10:01 AM

Editorial Consistency

Editor returns my manuscript. Red marks everywhere.

Page 1: 'Cliché.'
Page 2: 'Cliché.'
Page 3: 'Cliché.'
Page 4: 'Cliché.'

This continues for 312 pages.

Final note on last page:

'On the positive side: remarkably consistent voice throughout. Consider this a strength.'

editor feedback manuscript review clichés writing critique publishing

Joke Jan 26, 07:32 PM

The Tearful Comedy

Beta reader calls at midnight: "Chapter 5 made me cry."

Me: "It's a comedy."

Beta reader: "I know."

beta reader writing feedback comedy writing manuscript review

Joke Jan 19, 11:01 AM

The Beta Reader's Curse

My friend asked me to beta read her fantasy novel. 'Be brutally honest,' she said. I pointed out seventeen plot holes, four timeline inconsistencies, and a dragon that changed colors mid-chapter. She hasn't spoken to me in six months. Turns out 'brutally honest' is author-speak for 'praise me specifically but make it sound like feedback.'

beta reader writing feedback author sensitivity manuscript review writer friendship

Nothing to read? Create your own book and read it! Like I do.

1x

"Start telling the stories that only you can tell." — Neil Gaiman