Content Feed

Here's a dirty little secret the publishing industry doesn't want you to know: every masterpiece you've ever loved started as hot garbage. That pristine prose you worship? It was once a steaming pile of crossed-out sentences, coffee-stained pages, and existential dread. Hemingway said the first draft of anything is shit. He wasn't being humble — he was being clinical. And if Papa Hemingway's first drafts were trash, what makes you think yours should be any different?

Let's get one thing straight before we go any further. Your first draft is supposed to be bad. Not mediocre. Not rough-around-the-edges. Bad. Spectacularly, gloriously, embarrassingly bad. The sooner you accept this, the sooner you'll actually finish writing something. Because right now, I'd bet money you're stuck on page three of a novel you started two years ago, endlessly polishing a paragraph that doesn't matter yet.

Consider Tolstoy. The man rewrote War and Peace — all 1,225 pages of it — seven times. His wife Sophia hand-copied the entire manuscript each time, because photocopiers weren't exactly an option in the 1860s. Seven drafts. That means the first six versions of one of the greatest novels ever written were, by Tolstoy's own ruthless standards, not good enough. Draft one? Probably unrecognizable. And this was a genius. A titan of literature. A man whose sentences could make you weep. Even he needed seven swings at it.

Or take Fitzgerald and The Great Gatsby. The original title was "Trimalchio in West Egg." Let that sink in. One of the most iconic titles in American literature almost got saddled with a name that sounds like an Italian restaurant in the Hamptons. Fitzgerald's editor, Maxwell Perkins, talked him out of it. The early drafts were bloated, unfocused, and missing the precise economy of language that makes the final version sing. Fitzgerald slashed, restructured, rewrote entire chapters. The Gatsby you know was sculpted from a much uglier block of marble.

Here's where it gets interesting from a psychological standpoint. There's a phenomenon called the "inner critic" — that nasty little voice in your head that tells you every sentence is wrong the moment you type it. Neuroscience actually backs this up. Research from the University of Greifswald found that experienced writers literally suppress their dorsolateral prefrontal cortex — the brain's editing center — when drafting. They let the creative regions run wild and save the judgment for later. Novice writers? They keep the editor switched on the entire time, which is like trying to drive a car with one foot on the gas and the other on the brake. You'll burn out the engine and go nowhere.

Raymond Carver, the master of minimalist fiction, had a secret weapon: his editor Gordon Lish. Lish didn't just tweak Carver's stories — he gutted them. He cut "What We Talk About When We Talk About Love" by over fifty percent. Whole paragraphs, characters, subplots — gone. Some literary scholars argue Lish essentially co-authored Carver's most famous work. Controversial? Absolutely. But it proves a point: the magic isn't in the first draft. It's in the cutting room.

Now, I can already hear the objections. "But what about Kerouac? He wrote On the Road on a single scroll in three weeks!" Yeah, about that. First, Kerouac spent seven years taking notes, journaling, and mentally composing the book before that famous scroll session. Second, the scroll draft wasn't the published version. Viking Press made him revise it significantly. The myth of the spontaneous masterpiece is exactly that — a myth. Even the Beats, those champions of raw, unfiltered expression, edited their work.

Stephen King, in his memoir On Writing, describes the first draft as writing with the door closed. It's just you and the story. No audience, no expectations, no pressure. The second draft is writing with the door open — that's when you let the world in, when you start thinking about readers, clarity, pacing. King typically cuts ten percent of his word count between drafts. For a guy who writes eight-hundred-page novels, that's eighty pages hitting the trash. And King writes fast. He's prolific. He's confident. Even he knows the first pass isn't the finished product.

The real danger isn't writing a bad first draft. The real danger is perfectionism — the silent killer of more novels than writer's block ever was. Perfectionism is seductive because it masquerades as high standards. "I just want it to be good," you tell yourself, as you rewrite the opening sentence for the fortieth time. But perfectionism isn't about quality. It's about fear. Fear of judgment, fear of failure, fear of putting something imperfect into a world that's already drowning in content. And that fear will paralyze you if you let it.

Anne Lamott nailed this in her classic Bird by Bird when she coined the term "shitty first drafts." She wrote: "All good writers write them. This is how they end up with good second drafts and terrific third drafts." Lamott wasn't giving permission to be lazy. She was giving permission to be human. Because the alternative — demanding perfection on the first try — isn't ambition. It's delusion.

Let me give you a practical framework. Draft one is for you. It's the discovery phase. You're figuring out what the story is actually about, who the characters really are, where the plot actually wants to go. Half your outline will prove useless. Characters you planned as minor will demand center stage. Scenes you thought were crucial will feel dead on arrival. That's normal. That's the process working exactly as it should.

Draft two is for structure. Now you know what you've got, and you can start shaping it. Move scenes around. Cut the dead weight. Strengthen the through-line. This is where a book starts to look like a book instead of a fever dream transcription.

Draft three is for language. Now — and only now — do you start worrying about individual sentences, word choice, rhythm, the music of prose. Polishing words before you've locked down the structure is like choosing curtains for a house that doesn't have walls yet.

So here's my challenge to you. Go write something terrible today. Seriously. Open a document and let it rip. Write the worst, most clichéd, most structurally unsound thing you can. Give yourself permission to be embarrassingly bad. Because behind every polished masterpiece on your bookshelf sits a graveyard of awful first drafts — and the only difference between those published authors and you is that they had the guts to write the garbage first, and the patience to fix it after.