Iris Murdoch Died 27 Years Ago, and We Still Haven't Figured Out What the Hell She Was Talking About (That's the Point)

Here's a confession that might get me banned from every book club in London: I've read The Sea, the Sea three times, and I'm still not entirely sure whether the narrator is a genius, a lunatic, or just the most insufferable dinner party guest in literary history. That's not a criticism—that's the highest praise I can offer Iris Murdoch, who died on February 8th, 1999, leaving behind a body of work that continues to confuse, seduce, and occasionally infuriate readers who thought they knew what novels were supposed to do.

Twenty-seven years since Murdoch shuffled off this mortal coil, and here we are, still arguing about her books at wine bars, still assigning them in philosophy seminars, still discovering that the person we're dating has a suspiciously dog-eared copy of Under the Net on their nightstand (run or marry them immediately—there's no middle ground). The woman published twenty-six novels, and somehow managed to make each one feel like she was personally reaching into your skull and rearranging the furniture.

Let's talk about Under the Net for a moment, her 1954 debut that announced to the literary world: a new weird kid has arrived, and she's read way too much Sartre. Jake Donaghue stumbles through London like a philosophical pinball, bouncing between women, jobs, and existential crises with the grace of someone who's had three pints too many but insists they're fine to walk home. The novel reads like Murdoch took the French existentialists, dunked them in the Thames, and wrung them out over Soho. It shouldn't work. It absolutely works.

But here's where Murdoch gets genuinely dangerous: she was a trained philosopher, and unlike most academics who dabble in fiction, she didn't leave her brain at the university gates. Her novels aren't philosophical in the tedious way—no characters monologuing about Being and Nothingness while staring meaningfully at rain. Instead, she infected every scene, every dialogue, every description with genuine moral inquiry. You'd be reading about someone making tea and suddenly realize you were three pages deep into a meditation on attention, goodness, and whether love is even possible between two inherently selfish humans.

The Black Prince, published in 1973, might be her masterpiece—or her most elaborate practical joke on readers. Bradley Pearson, our narrator, is a pompous blocked writer who falls catastrophically in love with his rival's daughter. The novel comes wrapped in multiple forewords and postscripts from other characters, each contradicting Bradley's account. Who's telling the truth? Everyone. No one. The truth isn't the point. Murdoch seems to be cackling from beyond the pages: you wanted a reliable narrator? In THIS economy?

Then there's The Sea, the Sea, which won the Booker Prize in 1978 and remains one of the strangest books to ever claim that particular honor. Charles Arrowby, a retired theater director with an ego the size of the North Atlantic, retreats to a coastal house to write his memoirs and accidentally becomes obsessed with his childhood sweetheart. What follows is either a ghost story, a psychological thriller, a Buddhist parable, or the world's longest letter from a man who desperately needs therapy. Probably all four.

What makes Murdoch feel so urgently contemporary isn't her plots—which, let's be honest, often involve upper-middle-class English people having affairs in drawing rooms. It's her obsessive interest in how we lie to ourselves. Every Murdoch protagonist thinks they're the hero of their own story, acting from pure motives, seeing things clearly. And every Murdoch novel systematically demolishes that fantasy. In an age of carefully curated Instagram personas and main-character syndrome, reading her feels less like visiting the past and more like looking in a very unflattering mirror.

She also wrote about love in ways that make modern romance novels look like instruction manuals. Murdoch's love is violent, irrational, frequently misdirected, and absolutely devastating. Her characters don't fall in love—they plummet, often toward people who are terrible for them, often while being terrible themselves. She understood that desire isn't some pure force but something entangled with ego, projection, and the desperate need to not be alone with our own consciousness.

The philosophical underpinnings matter too. Murdoch studied under Wittgenstein at Cambridge, corresponded with existentialists, wrote serious works on Sartre and Plato. Her 1970 essay The Sovereignty of Good remains assigned reading in ethics courses, arguing that moral improvement requires learning to see reality clearly—to pay genuine attention to others rather than filtering everything through our own fantasies. Her novels are that theory in action, showing us characters who fail spectacularly at seeing anything clearly, inviting us to recognize ourselves in their blindness.

Twenty-seven years dead, and Murdoch's influence ripples through contemporary literature in ways we don't always notice. Every novelist who treats unreliable narration as a moral investigation rather than a mere trick owes her something. Every writer who asks whether their characters are truly free or just performing freedom is walking paths she mapped. The current boom in literary fiction that takes philosophy seriously without becoming unreadable? Murdoch was doing that when most of today's authors were in diapers.

Here's my controversial take: Murdoch is more relevant now than she was at her death. In 1999, we still believed in the possibility of authentic selfhood, of breaking through our delusions to some true core. Social media hadn't yet revealed how infinitely we can deceive ourselves while broadcasting that deception to thousands. Murdoch always knew. She spent her career anatomizing the gap between who we think we are and who we actually are, and that gap has only widened since she left.

If you haven't read her, start with Under the Net—it's short, funny, and relatively accessible. If that hooks you, move to The Black Prince for the full Murdoch experience: unsettling, brilliant, and guaranteed to make you trust narrators slightly less for the rest of your life. The Sea, the Sea requires commitment, but it rewards you with one of the most perfectly realized unreliable narrators in English literature.

Iris Murdoch was Dame Commander of the Order of the British Empire, a philosophical heavyweight, and by all accounts a genuinely weird person who kept a stuffed owl in her office and believed in the power of art to make us morally better. Whether that last belief was naïve or prophetic remains an open question—one she would have loved us to keep asking, probably while drinking red wine and talking about Plato.

She's been dead for twenty-seven years, and she's still the most interesting person at the party.